Side-by-side comparison

Payday Peanut Caramel Bar vs Halo Top Birthday Cake Ice Cream

Halo Top Birthday Cake Ice Cream wins by 22 points on FoodScore. Nutrient breakdown below — green values are better per field.

0/ 100

sweet

Payday Peanut Caramel Bar

Avoid · 1.85 ONZ

0/ 100

sweet

Halo Top Birthday Cake Ice Cream

Poor · 2/3 cup

Per 100gPayday Peanut Caramel BarHalo Top Birthday Cake Ice Cream

Calories461.54 kcal117.65 kcal

Protein13.46 g7.06 g

Fiber3.81 g3.51 g

Total fat25 g2.94 g

Saturated fat4.81 g1.18 g

Added sugar28.27 g4.7 g

Sodium230.77 mg158.82 mg

Potassium0 mg141.18 mg

Calcium76.92 mg164.71 mg

Iron1.38 mg0.24 mg

Comparison uses per-100g nutrient values from USDA FoodData Central. Each field is marked in green for the option that is healthier on that specific row — but the final FoodScore weighs all fields together plus processing level (NOVA) to produce a single 0–100 number.