Side-by-side comparison

PREMIER PROTEIN PUMPKIN SPICE HIGH PROTEIN SHAKE, PUMPKIN SPICE vs VEGA CHOCOLATE FLAVORED ALL-IN-ONE SHAKE DRINK MIX, CHOCOLATE

VEGA CHOCOLATE FLAVORED ALL-IN-ONE SHAKE DRINK MIX, CHOCOLATE wins by 24 points on FoodScore. Nutrient breakdown below — green values are better per field.

Verdict

FoodScore: PREMIER PROTEIN PUMPKIN SPICE HIGH PROTEIN SHAKE, PUMPKIN SPICE scores 48/100, VEGA CHOCOLATE FLAVORED ALL-IN-ONE SHAKE DRINK MIX, CHOCOLATE scores 72/100. VEGA CHOCOLATE FLAVORED ALL-IN-ONE SHAKE DRINK MIX, CHOCOLATE wins by 24 points on protein (47.6g vs 8.7g per 100 g) and fiber (9.5g vs 0.3g per 100 g).

0/ 100

beverage

PREMIER PROTEIN PUMPKIN SPICE HIGH PROTEIN SHAKE, PUMPKIN SPICE

Decent · 1 Shake

0/ 100

beverage

VEGA CHOCOLATE FLAVORED ALL-IN-ONE SHAKE DRINK MIX, CHOCOLATE

Good · 1 pack

Per 100gPREMIER PROTEIN PUMPKIN SPICE HIGH PROTEIN SHAKE, PUMPKIN SPICEVEGA CHOCOLATE FLAVORED ALL-IN-ONE SHAKE DRINK MIX, CHOCOLATE

Calories46.09 kcal357.14 kcal

Protein8.7 g47.62 g

Fiber0.3 g9.5 g

Total fat0.87 g11.9 g

Saturated fat0.14 g2.38 g

Added sugar0 g0 g

Sodium66.96 mg595.24 mg

Potassium80.87 mg666.67 mg

Calcium188.12 mg357.14 mg

Iron0.52 mg12.9 mg

Comparison uses per-100g nutrient values from USDA FoodData Central. Each field is marked in green for the option that is healthier on that specific row — but the final FoodScore weighs all fields together plus processing level (NOVA) to produce a single 0–100 number.