United States · 59 SKUs scored · avg 44/100
Elmhurst 1925
Elmhurst 1925 is a New York-based plant-milk producer that relaunched in 2017 after converting from conventional dairy. The Milked Oats and Milked Almonds lines use a cold-milling process that skips stabilizers, gums and added oils, keeping ingredient lists unusually short (just grain or nut plus water plus sometimes salt). The unsweetened variants stay in NOVA 2 and deliver meaningful protein. Our pages highlight the trade-off: Elmhurst costs more than Silk or Oatly but cleaner composition often translates into a higher FoodScore.
All Elmhurst 1925 SKUs, ranked
- ELMHURST FRENCH VANILLA LIGHTLY SWEETENED HEMP CREAMER, FRENCH VANILLA67
- ELMHURST HAZELNUT LIGHTLY SWEETENED HEMP CREAMER, HAZELNUT67
- ELMHURST DAIRY, SKIM FAT FREE MILK60
- ELMHURST DAIRY MILK60
- ELMHURST DAIRY REDUCED FAT MILK60
- ELMHURST VANILLA BEAN PROTEIN SHAKE, VANILLA BEAN59
- ELMHURST BARISTA EDITION OAT, BARISTA EDITION58
- ELMHURST BLUEBERRY MILKED OATS, BLUEBERRY58
- ELMHURST Milked Almonds Unsweetened58
- ELMHURST MILKED ALMONDS58
- ELMHURST MILKED BROWN RICE BARISTA EDITION58
- ELMHURST Milked Oats Original58
- ELMHURST MILKED OATS58
- ELMHURST MILKED WALNUTS58
- ELMHURST ORIGINAL MILKED OATS, ORIGINAL58
- ELMHURST PISTACHIO BARISTA EDITION58
- ELMHURST UNSWEETENED MILKED CASHEWS, UNSWEETENED58
- ELMHURST UNSWEETENED MILKED HAZELNUTS, UNSWEETENED58
- ELMHURST UNSWEETENED MILKED WALNUTS, UNSWEETENED58
- ELMHURST VANILLA FLAVORED MILKED OATS, VANILLA58
- ELMHURST VANILLA MILKED OATS, VANILLA58
- ELMHURST CHOCOLATE PEANUT PROTEIN SHAKE, CHOCOLATE PEANUT PROTEIN SHAKE46
- ELMHURST BARISTA EDITION HEMP, BARISTA EDITION45
- ELMHURST CACAO OAT LATTE, CACAO45
- ELMHURST CHOCOLATE MILKED OATS, CHOCOLATE45
- ELMHURST GOLDEN - MILK OAT LATTE, GOLDEN - MILK45
- ELMHURST MILKED HAZELNUTS45
- ELMHURST NATURALS ALL NATURAL BANANA JUICE CONCENTRATE, WITH NATURAL MANGO & PEACH FLAVORS45
- ELMHURST NATURALS BANANA WATER, PASSION FRUIT45
- ELMHURST NATURALS, ALL NATURAL BANANA JUICE CONCENTRATE, NATURAL BANANA, NATURAL BANANA45
- ELMHURST UNSWEETENED OAT CREAMER, UNSWEETENED45
- ELMHURST UNSWEETENED OAT CREAMER45
- ELMHURST VANILLA MILKED HEMP, VANILLA45
- ELMHURST HARVEST, REAL WALNUT BEVERAGE, ORIGINAL, ORIGINAL44
- ELMHURST HARVEST PREMIUM PISTACHIO BEVERAGE, ORIGINAL44
- ELMHURST HARVEST PREMIUM PISTACHIO BEVERAGE, UNSWEETENED44
- ELMHURST HARVEST PREMIUM PISTACHIO BEVERAGE, VANILLA44
- ELMHURST CHOCOLATE MILKED PEANUTS, CHOCOLATE40
- ELMHURST HARVEST PREMIUM WALNUT BEVERAGE, CHOCOLATE40
- ELMHURST PLANT BASED RICH & CREAMY OAT NOG38
- ELMHURST DAIRY HALF & HALF37
- ELMHURST NATURALS HORCHATA, CARAMEL36
- ELMHURST NATURALS HORCHATA, TRADITIONAL36
- ELMHURST NATURALS TRADITIONAL HORCHATA, CINNAMON & VANILLA36
- ELMHURST CARAMEL MACCHIATO LIGHTLY SWEETENED HEMP CREAMER, CARAMEL MACCHIATO25
- ELMHURST PEPPERMINT MOCHA LIGHTLY SWEETENED HEMP CREAMER, PEPPERMINT MOCHA25
- ELMHURST PISTACHIO CREME FLAVORED OAT CREAMER, PISTACHIO CREME25
- ELMHURST PUMPKIN SPICE LIGHTLY SWEETENED HEMP CREAMER, PUMPKIN SPICE25
- ELMHURST DAIRY, HEAVY CREAM24
- ELMHURST DAIRY HEAVY CREAM24
- ELMHURST APPLE PIE SPICE OAT CREAMER, APPLE PIE SPICE23
- ELMHURST CREAMER PLANT BASED OAT, CHAI SPICE23
- ELMHURST FRENCH VANILLA FLAVORED PLANT BASED OAT CREAMER, FRENCH VANILLA23
- ELMHURST FRENCH VANILLA OAT CREAMER23
- ELMHURST GINGERBREAD OAT CREAMER, GINGERBREAD23
- ELMHURST HAZELNUT OAT CREAMER, HAZELNUT23
- ELMHURST LAVENDER VANILLA OAT CREAMER, LAVENDER VANILLA23
- ELMHURST PLANT BASED CHAI SPICE OAT CREAMER23
- ELMHURST NATURALS HORCHATA18
Data source: USDA FoodData Central, Branded Foods dataset. Nutrition Facts values, ingredient lists and UPCs are manufacturer-declared. FoodScore methodology is documented on the methodology page. Manufacturer website: elmhurst1925.com.